In The Mountain and the Sea, Ray Nayler packs every idea he's had into the novel. Pretty common for a first novel, and it turned into a really provocative book. Didn't like at first or even at second, but in the end it fascinated me. So I gave him another try with this one.
I would say the characters are consistent with those in his first novel, but much less developed. Nayler has no sympathetic protagonists, only variously broken or stubborn people. This makes him interesting as an author. But as others say, the characters here are quite thin, just vehicles for ideas. And we know these ideas, we are reading them in the news. Nayler does show us that people in the Federation, the Union and the Republic have all given up their freedom and agency in what are seemingly different but really quite similar ways. Books are usually put to bed 18 months or more from when they are written, so the fact that he captures the general sense of technological development, including at the very end, is impressive. Not sorry I read it, but I think he can do better.Thursday, November 19, 2026
Lord of Light, by Roger Zelazny
I first read this book 50 years ago, when I was a teenager. Shortly after it first came out. Mostly what I thought was how different it was from his other, more interesting books. But it sure got a lot of critical acclaim, being so different from the science fiction being written in the 60's.
Read it again this year for a book club. SF is much more diverse now than it was then, and the innovation is a thin veneer. Hindu cosplay wrapped in flowery language. So much less than meets the eye. I give it 3 stars for historical significance.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Where the Axe is Buried, Ray Nayler
In The Mountain and the Sea, Ray Nayler packs every idea he's had into the novel. Pretty common for a first novel, and it turned into a ...
-
I'm starting on the novella nominations for Nebula, and began with The Dream-Quest of Vellitt Boe . This is her commentary on The Dream...
-
There are some interesting theories out there on what Gene Wolfe's "The Ziggurat" short story means . Indeed, Wolfe is heavil...
-
The introduction to Slow Tuesday Night is by Gardner Dozios, the great editor, and he tells us that "only those stories that were the ...